The Carbon Credit Debate

“Environmental movements of the last few decades have brought about interest in reducing emissions through the use of carbon credit, carbon taxes and other economic tools. These abstract implements are the results of international policies that were designed by several nations seeking to limit the emissions of greenhouse gases and alter the way that humans affect the global environment. So far many nations have agreed to use the system that requires these economic certificates in order to cooperate in preserving the Earth’s environment.

Exactly What Is A Carbon Credit?

This is a term that really refers to any permit or certificate, whether actually printed or kept in digital form, which allows the holder to emit a metric ton carbon dioxide or any other recognized greenhouse gas in an equivalent quantity. Companies sell these credits, primarily to commercial customers, after purchasing them from carbon development projects. They are a political product of the Kyoto Protocol, to which 170 countries agreed.

How They Reduce Emissions

A carbon credit assigns a financial value to pollution. Using these certificates and including them in a company’s expenses makes pollution part of a business balance sheet. The emissions produced by a company are thus listed along with a company’s liabilities and assets. As an example, a company may normally churn out 10,000 metric tons of carbon emissions each year as part of its normal operations. If the country in which this company operates passes legislation limiting all such companies to only 7,000 tons of emissions, the company is confronted with a choice. It can find a way to lower emissions to that level or it can purchase carbon credits from approved vendors which will allow it to surpass that limit.

Carbon Taxes

Carbon taxes are another form of carbon pricing with the same intent. They force pollution-emitting businesses to face consequences for their emissions. For every metric ton of carbon emitted over a certain level, a tax is assessed. Companies are free to emit what they want, as long as they pay the taxes for those emissions.

Opposition

The utilization of carbon credits, carbon taxes and most any form of carbon pricing or regulation has some vocal critics. These critics point out both flaws in the implementation of these regulations as well as fundamental errors in the creation of these policies. Their criticism can be boiled down to two essential points.

These carbon pricing efforts, particularly carbon taxes, function as regressive taxes because these business expenses are passed along to the consumer. Individual poor people are more likely to have to pay for more of these costs than are businesses and the wealthy. In the end, according to these critics, carbon pricing actually hurts the people it was meant to defend.
It is not clear how these efforts actually lower emissions. If businesses simply pass the expenses of carbon credits and carbon taxes onto the consumer and continue churning out pollution, then it just makes profits for the vendors of carbon credit and the governments who impose the taxes.”

If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it!
Icon Icon Icon

Related Posts